Jump To Content
Cooperative Learning

Debates in Cooperative Learning

Competition kills cooperation

7 Posts

nelliemuller
  • Authority 559
Post Body
nelliemuller said:

Competition kills cooperation when everyone focuses on promoting their personal and professional interests. Attle and Baker (2007) suggested, “Both competition and cooperation potentially impact student performance” (p. 77).

Attle, S., & Baker, B. (2007). Cooperative learning in a competitive environment: Classroom applications. International Journal of Teaching and Learning in Higher Education, 19(1), 77-83. Retrieved March 15, 2008, from http://www.isetl.org/ijtlhe/pdf/IJTLHE19.pdf#page=80

  • Quote
  • Posted 5 months ago.
NormGreen
  • Authority 400
Post Body
NormGreen disagreed:

Hello I am passionate in my belief that students need opportunity to work with others in environments that support discussion and debate. But like the authors mentioned in the article from the Journal of Teaching and Learning, I believe in a balance between cooperation and competitive learning. “Tauer and Harackiewicz (2004) found that by combining cooperative group learning with inter-group competition intrinsic motivation of participants consistently improved. The findings suggest that a combination of cooperation and competition facilitates motivation, enjoyment, and performance of participants. The implications for professional preparation indicate the student benefits of combining cooperative team learning strategies structured in an inter-group competition.” So does a balance between the two or a combination of the two lead to a richer learning experience?

  • Quote
  • Posted 4 months ago.
Toon
  • Authority 52
Post Body
Toon agreed:

What we have experienced here in Vietnam is that integrating the two in a learning process, can be realized and adds to the joy and quality of learning. I’ld be happy to share details with you on our work, but most of the “products” (i.e. lesson plans and videos) are in Vietnamese.

  • Quote
  • Posted 4 months ago.
nelliemuller
  • Authority 559
Post Body
nelliemuller agreed:

Hi Toon,

Can you explain what you do? What kind of lessons do you develop that encourage both competition and cooperation?

Thank you.

  • Quote
  • Posted 4 months ago.
Toon
  • Authority 52
Post Body
Toon agreed:

Hi Nellie, We develop teacher training programs that aim at buidling capacity for teachers to bring enviornmental education and at the same time promote a more learner centered approach. Our competition brought together teachers who work in similar contexts (level of students and/or subjects) and promoted sharing through “teaching competitions”. I don’t know whether this is the right place to explain all details, but from what I observed, competition can promote sharing.

  • Quote
  • Posted 4 months ago.
nelliemuller
  • Authority 559
Post Body
nelliemuller agreed with:
Toon
Toon’s post:
Citation Body

Hi Nellie, We develop teacher training programs that aim at buidling capacity for teachers to bring enviornmental education and at the same time promote a more learner centered approach. Our competition brought together teachers who work in similar contexts (level of students and/or subjects) and promoted sharing through “teaching competitions”. I don’t know whether this is the right place to explain all details, but from what I observed, competition can promote sharing.

How does competition promote sharing in the program?

  • Quote
  • Posted 4 months ago.
Toon
  • Authority 52
Post Body
Toon agreed:

In our case, teachers were invited to share in working groups that brought them together with other teachers who “compete” in the same “category”. The competitive element motivated teachers to ask their peers more detailed questions on contents, methodology, materials, evaluation, aims… The focus was not so much on who is “best” but on who “excelled”. OK?

  • Quote
  • Posted 4 months ago.
  • You will be able to edit your reply for 10 minutes after you post it.

Stats

  • 7 Posts

Activity
Feed-icon-12x12